Why Workers Are Reluctant to Swap Hard Hats for Safety Helmets

Last August, I took my pickup to the dealership to figure out why my check engine light wouldn’t turn off. While my truck was being inspected, I struck up a conversation with my usual salesman, who excitedly told me about the new 2025 models. He raved about the twin-turbo inline six-cylinder engine, confidently claiming it could outperform my V8 in every category.
"It’ll even tow your travel trailer better, I swear! You need to at least take a drive while we’re checking out your truck," he urged. Skeptical but curious, I took his advice. To my surprise, he was right. I had been so loyal to my V8 that I hadn’t considered a smaller engine could deliver better performance, even with forced induction.
.jpg)
By the time my truck was ready, I was handed not just a hefty repair estimate but also a trade-in offer that would make the repair cost disappear. The next drive home from the dealership? It was in that new truck I swore I wouldn’t buy just days before.
The Connection Between Workers and Their Gear
As I transferred my personal belongings from my old truck to the new one, I grabbed my safety helmet from behind the driver’s seat and placed it in the same spot. The salesman, who knew I worked in workplace safety, noticed it and chuckled.
"Wow, I bet that Robo-Cop hard hat gets a lot of laughs. Do people actually wear those?" he asked. His remark made me pause.
That moment stuck with me because it highlighted how much of our identity is tied to what we wear. Whether it’s a well-worn pair of boots, a favorite ball cap, or a hard hat, workers form strong attachments to their gear. In construction, the classic Type 1 hard hat has been a symbol of the trade for decades. It’s not just about protection—it’s about familiarity and tradition. So, when safety helmets with chin straps and a different fit start replacing them, workers don’t just see a new piece of equipment; they see an attempt to change their culture.
The Benefits of Type 2 Safety Helmets
Despite the resistance, safety helmets offer significantly better protection than traditional hard hats. Standard hard hats are primarily designed to shield against top-down impacts, such as falling debris. However, construction workers face a variety of hazards—slips, trips, lateral impacts, and falls. Type 2 helmets provide protection from both top and side impacts, reducing the risk of serious head injuries. Additionally, their chin straps ensure that the helmet stays securely in place during a fall, unlike a hard hat that could fly off on impact.
Why Workers Resist the Switch
Even with these advantages, many workers hesitate to adopt safety helmets. The reasons are clear:
- Comfort Issues: Hard hats provide ventilation through their suspension system, which many helmets lack, making them feel hotter.
- Sun Protection: Many workers rely on the full brim of a hard hat for shade, something most helmets don’t offer.
- Ease of Use: Workers are used to simply throwing on their hard hats without adjusting a chin strap.
When workers say safety helmets are uncomfortable, they aren’t wrong. Many designs sacrifice breathability, and without a brim, workers lose essential sun protection. These concerns are valid, and they require real solutions.
The Safety Culture Shift
My experience at the dealership reminded me of a critical lesson: sometimes, you need a "test drive" to believe in new technology. Safety professionals can win workers over by explaining why they’re making the switch. Simply saying, "It’s required by the GC," won’t improve safety culture. Instead, workers need to understand exactly how these helmets enhance their safety and how much their well-being means to their employers—enough to invest five to seven times the cost of a traditional hard hat.
That being said, helmets shouldn’t sacrifice features that workers rely on. At Malta Dynamics, we believe in listening to workers and building products that meet their needs. That’s why we developed a helmet that looks like a hard hat while incorporating the superior safety features of a Type 2 helmet. It meets the strictest general contractor requirements but maintains the style and functionality workers are comfortable with—all at a price of $69.99, nearly half the cost of many competitors.
Try It for Yourself
Just like I needed to experience that new truck to believe in its capabilities, workers need to try out a helmet that meets both safety and comfort needs. If you're looking for upgraded head protection for your crew, we’re offering a test drive. Click here, and we’ll send you one of our APEX Type 2 full-brim safety helmets to try out—because better safety shouldn’t mean giving up what you love about your gear.
Originally reported by Greg Brown President - Malta Dynamics in Construction Dive.
The smartest construction companies in the industry already get their news from us.
If you want to be on the winning team, you need to know what they know.
Our library of marketing materials is tailored to help construction firms like yours. Use it to benchmark your performance, identify opportunities, stay up-to-date on trends, and make strategic business decisions.
Join Our Community